If you were injured on a worksite, it’s likely that more than one business may be legally responsible for the accident. Companies often work together in a wide variety of ventures, under which they share their resources and capabilities in order to both make money. These ventures can create a tangled web for liability purposes, as the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of West Virginia recently explained.
Mr. Young was killed in a tragic accident while working for Apogee Coal Company at the Guyan Mine in Logan County. He was removing a more than 11,000-pound counterweight from a machine when the counterweight fell on top of Young and killed him. Young’s wife later sued the company, alleging that it didn’t properly train Young in how to remove the counterweight before his supervisor ordered him to complete the task. She also sued Apogee’s holding company, Patriot Coal Corporation. Ms. Young argued that Patriot was vicariously liable for Apogee’s negligence and asserted that the companies were involved in a joint venture.
Denying Patriot’s motion to dismiss the vicarious liability claim, the District Court said Ms. Young pleaded sufficient facts to show that the company may be liable for the accident. Young claimed that Patriot should be liable because it had an agency relationship with Apogee. Although a parent company isn’t generally responsible for the actions of a subsidiary, it may be liable if the subsidiary can be deemed its agent. While the Court didn’t define such a relationship in detail, it did say that “[o]ne of the essential elements of an agency relationship is the existence of some degree of control by the principal over the conduct and activities of the agent.”
Here, Young claimed that Apogee ran the Mine under Patriot’s direction and control and that Patriot maintained the right to make day-to-day business decisions about the Mine’s operation. She also asserted that Patriot knew of and even sanctioned Apogee’s violation of various mine safety standards at Guyan. “[T]hese allegations sufficiently allege that Patriot Coal exercised control over the conduct of Apogee Coal requisite to an agency relationship,” the Court explained.
Turning to the joint venture claims, the Court said the pleadings fell short of establishing that the two companies were operating such a venture. A joint venture “is an association of two or more persons to carry out a single business enterprise for profit, for which purpose they combine their property, money, effects, skill, and knowledge,” according to the Court. One participant in the venture may be liable for that acts of the other.
In this case, the Court noted that Young alleged that the two companies worked closely together and that Patriot exercised some degree of control over the Mine operations. Patriot arranged for the sale of coal from the Mine, for example, and provided technical and administrative support to Apogee for its work at Guyan. She also alleged that the companies combined money, property, skills, and knowledge for the purpose of running the Mine.
The Court nevertheless dismissed the claim, finding that Young didn’t claim that Apogee actually had a legal right to control the Mine. Thus, while the two companies appeared to be jointly involved in running the operation, they couldn’t be said to be both carrying out the enterprise. Instead, it appeared that Apogee was simply following directions from Patriot.
As this case makes clear, claims against large companies like those in the coal industry can raise complicated issues related to liability. It’s important to discuss these and other issues with an experienced legal professional.
If you or a loved one has been injured in an accident at work in West Virginia, the Wolfe Law Firm can help. Our worksite accident lawyers have been serving clients throughout the state for more than 25 years. Located in Elkins, West Virginia, the firm represents clients in a wide range of injury, criminal defense, and bankruptcy matters. Call us at 1-877-637-5756 or contact us online for a free consultation.
Related blog posts: